Gill V Evansville Sheet Metal Works

It has long been settled that a preemption analysis begins with the presumption that.

Gill v evansville sheet metal works. Esmw allegedly worked as a contractor for al coa at a common work site with gale gill where materials containing asbestos were present and or used appellant s app. Summary judgment is improper if the moving party fails to carry its burden but if it succeeds then the non moving party must come forward with evidence establishing the existence of a genuine issue of material fact. Evansville sheet metal works 970 n e 2d 633 ind. 49s05 1111 cv 672 justia opinion summary.

We are asked to consider whether summary judgment for esmw on gill s negligence claim was proper. Evansville sheet metal works inc 970 n e 2d 633 637 ind. Appellant plaintiff sharon gill sharon on her own behalf and on behalf of the estate of her husband gale gill gale appeals the trial court s grant of appellee defendant s evansville sheet metal works inc. Evansville sheet metal works inc.

Gill appealed the trial court s ruling that the csor barred her contractor negligence claim and the court of appeals affirmed. Evansville sheet metal works inc 940 n e 2d 328 330 ind. Plaintiff claimed that her husband s death was caused by defendant s negligence in installing or removing asbestos containing materials and brought product liability and contractor negligence claims against defendant. Indiana case law defines fixtures and the best discussion comes from the indiana supreme court in gill v.

Evansville sheet metal works inc 970 n e 2d 633 637 ind. Gill sought and we granted transfer gill v. Summary judgment is improper if the movant fails to carry its burden but if it succeeds then the nonmoving party must come forward with evidence establishing the existence of a genuine issue of material fact. Brownsburg 963 n e 2d 453 457 ind.

Evansville sheet metal works inc 970 n e 2d 633 637 n 4 ind. June 25 2012 docket number. 60 years of experience the latest in laser waterjet and other cnc cutting technologies make esmw your best choice for custom metal fabrication. Standard principles of federal preemption guide this analysis.

Citing to older indiana cases the court stated.